Visualizing Sector Rotation Stock Performance

Mar 28, 2012: 10:57 AM CST

As a follow-up to yesterday’s “Bullish Sector Rotation Model” post, let’s take a moment to clarify how investors and traders can use top-level Sector Rotation themes to their advantage.

Traders and investors often use the model – or at least compare sector relative performance – to pinpoint trading or investing opportunities from the strongest stocks in the strongest sectors during bull/rally phases in the market.

The alternate strategy would be to locate the weakest stocks in the weakest sectors during a down or bear phase in the market.

As mentioned in the prior update, the Financial and Technology sectors – as viewed using the AMEX Sector ETFs XLF and XLK – are the top performers so far in 2012 (year to date to the end of March 2012).

Let’s take it one step further and view the largest five stocks in these two leading ETFs, first with Technology (XLK):

The chart above shows the price performance of five leading Technology stocks so far in 2012.

While the XLK – broader Technology ETF – is up 20% year to date, some stocks rose more than that while other technology stocks did not rise as much.

Generally speaking, the best trading and investment opportunities develop from the stronger stocks in a strong sector, which can be defined using Fundamental Analysis or even Technical Analysis (charting trends and relative performance).

You want to put your money in the best stocks in sectors that are outperforming the broader market – and at a minimum, avoid buying the weakest stocks in the weakest sectors.

This type of logic is along the lines of the phrase “Buy High, Sell Higher.”

Anyway, it should be no surprise that the top performer in the group is Apple (AAPL) but it may be surprising to learn that Google (GOOG) is the underperformer so far – notching only a 1.5% gain so far in 2012.

The image below helps us visualize a stock’s location not just within its sector, but within the broader market as well:

If we start with the broader market, we can then break the market down into nine (or ten) major sectors.

At times in the business/economic cycle, certain sectors will outperform others – and the broader stock market as well.

Individual stocks group together to make up the sectors, which are tracked easily using the AMEX Sector SPDR ETFs.

There’s a variety of ways to view both sector and stock performance, and it can be helpful to take the time to do so – visualizing each stock as part of a broader picture (its sector) which then is part of the Stock Market as a whole.

Here’s a performance chart for the other Sector leader in 2012:  The Financial Sector (XLF)

We see a similar picture in Financials as we see in Technology – Bank of America (BAC) outperformed the other leading companies in the sector, while Berkshire Hathaway (BRK/B) was an under-performer so far.

While the broader Sector ETF is up 22%, some stocks rose well above that amount year to date.

Notice also that Bank of America – BAC – started the year in the strongest position and remains there as of the end of March.

Berkshire Hathaway started the weakest stock in this ‘top 5’ list and is currently positioned there as well.

And finally, let’s take a quick look at the Utilities (XLU) Sector, which has been this year’s under-performer into March:

Again, the broader XLU Sector ETF is down 2.2% year to date and most of the ‘big five’ stocks in the ETF are also down for the year.

Keep in mind that the Utilities Sector is a Defensive/Protective sector group and is expected to under-perform during periods of stock market bullishness/rallies.

The under-performer in the group so far is Exelon (EXC) while the “out-performer” is NextEra Energy (NEE).

The main lesson to me is that we shouldn’t try to pick the best stock in a bad sector – the only leading stock that is positive for the year is NEE which is up less than 1%.

Contrast this with the worst “top 5” performer in Technology – Google – which is up 1.5% and the worst “top 5” Financial performer – Berkshire Hathaway – up almost 7%.

We’re reminded again that “The Trend is Your Friend” – particularly with sector trends and performance relative to the broader market.

Swing Traders in particular can benefit from taking the extra step to analyze sector and leading stock performance.

Corey Rosenbloom, CMT
Afraid to

Follow Corey on Twitter:

Corey’s new book The Complete Trading Course (Wiley Finance) is now available!


3 Responses to “Visualizing Sector Rotation Stock Performance”

  1. Wednesday links: kicking it real hard | Abnormal Returns Says:

    […] A look at how the big stocks in some leading sectors are performing.  (Afraid to Trade) […]

  2. Wednesday links: kicking it real hard Says:

    […] A look at how the big stocks in some leading sectors are performing.  (Afraid to Trade) […]

  3. luanmmxiigm Says:

    I don't have idea regarding this, but this post give me some ideas. 
    I am really not into business matters but somehow this make me interested.Thanks!

    Rogue from tronçonneuse électrique