Another Bull Trap and Lesson from Crude Oil

Mar 5, 2014: 1:08 PM CST

Bull Traps are the enemy of Breakout Traders, and it’s important to learn the educational reference lessons when these scenarios trigger.

Goal #1 is to protect yourself from escalating losses on a breakout opportunity that failed and Goal #2 (for aggressive traders only) is to profit from a trade outcome failure by playing into the “larger than expected move in the opposite direction.”

Let’s take a look at the recent breakout and failure – trap – in Crude Oil and step inside the price action to build a foundation for understanding what’s going on and how to protect ourselves.

Here’s the Daily Chart of Crude Oil and the resulting “Bull Trap” that triggered this morning:

Crude Oil Bull Trap Daily Chart Pattern Trade Failure Stop Loss

Without going into too much detail, let’s just reference the $103.50 area as an upper resistance key inflection level where a break above this level triggered a breakout opportunity into “Open Air” and a movement down against this level – especially with the divergences – triggered an aggressive “divergence into resistance” short-sell/bearish opportunity.

Monday’s Ukraine news thrust Crude Oil (and Gold) into potential breakout trade trigger mode as Money Flow took a Risk-Off posture.

Tuesday’s “Everything’s OK – Don’t Worry” news reversed these developments and Money Flow quickly shifted back to “Risk-On” Mode which thrust the S&P 500 to all-time highs.

Gold and Crude Oil suffered a reversal after initial breakouts, and buyers rushed to cover losing positions as short-sellers took the break under the $103.50 and $103 level as new trade entry triggers.

Here’s a peek inside the intraday chart with the Fibonacci Grid as a reference level:

Crude Oil Hourly Intraday Bull Trap Fibonacci Trade Failure

Again, a technical (chart) breakout triggered above $103.50 but failed just as quickly when price gapped and traded down under this inflection or pivot level.

The result – at least so far – has been a collapse straight down away from $103.50’s key level down toward the initial target which was just achieved (the prior price and 50% Fibonacci Level into $101.00).

Note the Momentum Divergences that preceded both the January low (reversal up) and the expected March reversal down that was thwarted by a day of Bull Trap activity.

Let’s step the perspective in one more time to a Pure Price and “Value Area” Profile Chart:

Crude Oil Market Profile value Area Bull Trap Outcome Targets

Fibonacci and indicators aside, we see a Clear Value Area with upper resistance into $103.50 and lower support near $101.50.  The Midpoint thus exists into the $102.50 level.

A break above the resistance high “Advertises Opportunity” (to use a Market Profile term) for buyers to step in and drive price away from Value.

On an initial break, buyers were unable to continue to push price higher and sellers became dominant on the “Everything is Ok/Don’t Worry” news.

From a price standpoint, sellers returned price to the upper resistance line ($103.50) and then pushed under it to trigger the resulting downside ‘collapse’ or return back to Value ($102.50) then the lower support target.

While we can’t predict which breakouts will succeed or fail, we can “predict” (at least from a high probability standpoint) that if price does trigger a Trap scenario like this, then we can expect price to return back to “Value” or a lower price target.

In other words, if you take a breakout trade opportunity like this, be ready to honor your stop if price does trade back under the breakout level.

Failure to trigger a stop-loss on a return under the breakout price exposes you to losses that mount quickly as price moves quickly down away from resistance.

If you didn’t take the breakout, or if you took the stop-loss without hesitation, aggressive traders have an opportunity to play the downward reaction that has trapped (in this case) buyers as they rush to liquidate losing positions at lower prices.

Use prior examples to continue to develop your knowledge on this important concept:

Lessons from the August SP500 Bull Trap

Quick Lessons from Three Bull Trap Outcomes

Always remember that it’s not your fault, and that the market isn’t “out to get you” if you get caught in a Bull or Bear Trap scenario.

Afraid to Trade Premium Content and Membership

Follow along with members of the Daily Commentary and Idealized Trades summaries for real-time updates and additional trade planning.

Corey Rosenbloom, CMT
Afraid to Trade.com

Follow Corey on Twitter:  http://twitter.com/afraidtotrade

Corey’s new book The Complete Trading Course (Wiley Finance) is now available along with the newly released Profiting from the Life Cycle of a Stock Trend presentation (also from Wiley).

5 Comments

5 Responses to “Another Bull Trap and Lesson from Crude Oil”

  1. Igor Marinkovic Says:

    Great example of bull trap, as it was said many times before from false moves come fast move.
    Thank you

  2. Quick Resistance Trade Planning in Goldman Sachs GS | Afraid to Trade.com Blog Says:

    […] Price then returned to the lower support line as is often the case with a Bull Trap Scenario and Outcome. […]

  3. Quick Resistance Trade Planning in Goldman Sachs GS — Trading Your Own Way Says:

    […] Price then returned to the lower support line as is often the case with a Bull Trap Scenario and Outcome. […]

  4. Charting the March Breakout into Open Air for Gold | Afraid to Trade.com Blog Says:

    […] $1,350 – meaning we don’t see an immediate return under $1,350 to trigger a violent Bull Trap Scenario and Outcome – then the tradable expectation is that price will continue its upward impulse (see August […]

  5. Charting the March Breakout into Open Air for Gold — Trading Your Own Way Says:

    […] hold above $1,350 – meaning we don’t see an immediate return under $1,350 to trigger a violent Bull Trap Scenario and Outcome – then the tradable expectation is that price will continue its upward impulse (see August 2013) […]