Sector Rotation Insights and Lessons from 2011

Jan 4, 2012: 1:45 PM CST

The fact that the S&P 500 “did nothing” in 2011 fails to take into account the performance of the individual sectors of the stock market, some of which returned as much as 15% in 2011.

Let’s review Sector Performance in 2011, learn insights into the Sector Rotation Model, and see where capital flowed during the “lackluster” 2011.

First, the classic Sector Performance Chart for 2011:

According to the Sector Rotation Model, we divide the market into two major categories:  Offensive Sectors and Defensive Sectors.

Offensive Sectors tend to outperform the S&P 500 during rallies or bullish phases, while the Defensive/Protective Sectors tend to outperform the S&P 500 during declines or bearish phases.

From the two categories, we then break the stock market down into 9 main sectors which are easily reflected above using the AMEX Sector SPDRs.

From the Model, we glean information where to focus our capital or look for individual trading opportunities:

Traders look to buy leading stocks in outperforming sectors during up-phases, short-sell or hedge with weak stocks in weak sectors during down-phases, or otherwise play a combination of the two broader strategies.

So what did 2011 tell us in terms of Sector Performance?

The DEFENSIVE or Protective Sectors outperformed the Offensive Sectors and the S&P 500 in 2011, suggesting investor caution.

All three Defensive Sectors – Health Care, Consumer Staples, and Utilities – roughly tied for best performance of 2011 near a 15% annual gain – that’s compared to the 0% gain of the S&P 500.

In terms of the Offensive Sectors (Consumer Discretionary, Financials, Technology, Industrials and Materials), two beat the S&P (Discretionary and Technology), one tied it (Industrials) and two underperformed it (Financials and Materials).

Again, this is NOT the picture of Stock Market confidence or outright bullishness – if investors are optimistic about the future, you’d expect to see them concentrate their investments (or trading activity) in the OFFENSIVE Sectors instead of the Defensive ones.

Let’s pull the picture back to see the performance of Offensive and Defensive Sectors with the S&P:

What we’re seeing above is the full 2011 Percentage Chart Performance of the Three Defensive (XLP, XLV, XLU) Sector ETFs with the S&P 500 (red).

Take a look at these in terms of rallies and declines in the S&P 500.

Being Defensive, these stocks tend to hold up (fall less) during down-phases yet underperform (rise less) during big bullish moves.

You can also see that these Three Sectors made HIGHER LOWS (did not push to new 2011 lows) during the October S&P 500 bottom – that’s worth referencing.

With the exception of the August sell-off and the November retracement, these sectors maintained a consistent upward pathway throughout 2011, unlike the Stock Market.

Again, this suggests investor caution, hedging, or otherwise lackluster enthusiasm for a bullish stock market.

Let’s turn now to the Offensive Performance Chart for 2011:

This chart is more jumbled due to the 5 Offensive Sectors, but follow along with the general patterns relative to the red S&P 500 line.

Notice how Consumer Discretionary, Technology, and Industrials mostly followed the performance of the S&P 500 all year, particularly into the close where the lines are almost identical.

Discretionary outperformed the S&P 500 for most of the year, ending as the strongest Offensive Sector with an increase of 5%.

The other interesting points are the Materials (XLB) sector which underperformed the S&P the whole year, ending down 10% and of course the Financial (XLF) sector which grossly underperformed the S&P 500, ending the year down almost 20%.

I can’t tell you how many times I heard the logic:

I’m going to buy the Financials because they’re the underperformers and just have to bounce back.

Wrong.

The main insight from the Sector Rotation Model is that sectors which are OUT-performing tend to CONTINUE to out-perform, while sectors which are UNDER-performing tend to CONTINUE to under-perform – the same logic is generally true with individual stocks.

Yes, there’s something to be said about contrary thinking, but “because something is cheap” should never be the sole reason to purchase a stock or sector – always look for other factors because without support, that which is currently cheap often continues to get cheaper.

That’s probably the main take-away from the Sector Rotation Model of 2011 – Sectors that started off strong continued to be strong throughout the year while sectors that started out weak tended to remain weak all year.  This was true for Materials as well.

For the most part, the sector performance relative to the S&P 500 (Defensive/Offensive) by May/June tended to continue throughout the rest of the year.

Anyway, continue studying the line and performance charts of the Sector Rotation Model and be ready to apply these lessons to 2012.

Corey Rosenbloom, CMT
Afraid to Trade.com

Follow Corey on Twitter:  http://twitter.com/afraidtotrade

Corey’s new book The Complete Trading Course (Wiley Finance) is now available!

9 Comments

9 Responses to “Sector Rotation Insights and Lessons from 2011”

  1. Tennessean Says:

    Great article. Check the following sentence at the beginning.  “Offensive Sectors tend to outperform the S&P 500 during rallies or
    bearish phases, while the Defensive/Protective Sectors tend to
    outperform the S&P 500 during declines or bearish phases.” I believe the first “bearish phase” should read “bullish phase”.

  2. Corey Rosenbloom, CMT Says:

    You're 100% correct!  I was typing that sentence too quickly apparently.  Thank you for letting me know.

  3. Ray French Says:

    Good article but simply the US is a credit society, no problem with that except the concept of lending money from the 1960ies and making it cheaper to borrow as the years went by and introduce more people to credit has to end or correct at some time. Quantitive easing and the US printing money for more than 30 years has led to a burn out of risk taking hence the low volume in the markets.  The markets are so volatile because of instant trading of indicies who wants to risk “Real” money in equities.  Welcome to the REAL world stop blaming Europe because the US created that beast by imitation. Like the Mobile replaces the house phone, the internet replaces posted letters and communication, what is replacing paper certificates, internet financial gambling that reacts to any limp news.  Do you ever see the TOTAL unemployment figure mentioned ?? no just jobs added or lost. This is a society bred to spend, the piper has to be paid unless we all get 2000 credit cards…

  4. Amit Says:

    Great article. I follow your blog regularly from Singapore and find it very useful.

  5. Thursday links: paused portfolios | Abnormal Returns Says:

    […] The highlights of sector rotation in 2011.  (Afraid to Trade) […]

  6. Thursday links: paused portfolios Says:

    […] The highlights of sector rotation in 2011.  (Afraid to Trade) […]

  7. theyenguy Says:

    Inestors fears in July 2011 that a debt union had formed in the Euro zone, precipitated global competitive currency deflation. Beginning in September 2011, the US Dollar, $USD, began to rise, and there was a flight to safety in Dollar Stocks particularly Energy Partnerships, AMJ, Pharmaceuticals, IHE, Health Care, XLV, Staples, XLP, Utilities, XLU, Dividend Payers, DVY, DTN, as seen in this Yahoo Finance Chart AMJ, IHE, XLV, XLP, XLU, DVY, DTN. I do not expect these to continue to be safe haven investments in 2012. It may be that the commodity gasoline, UGA, may have bottomed out in price, and may be headed somewhat higher in 2012, because there is a global Eurasia War coming which will be centered in Syria and also in Iran. For more commentary and charts http://tinyurl.com/7emqprv. I strongly recommend that one take profits and start to dollar average an investment in gold bullion at this time and keep the coins in multiple safe places, like a gun safe.

  8. Bullish Signs from the March 2012 Sector Rotation Model | Afraid to Trade.com Blog Says:

    […] “Sector Rotation Lessons and Insights from 2011″ (important reference post) […]

  9. Bullish Signs from the March 2012 Sector Rotation Model | Investing Advisers Says:

    […] “Sector Rotation Lessons and Insights from 2011? (important reference post) […]